Living with organisations

In a strange way, community organising is both about organisations and not about organisations! On the one hand, the famous definition of community organising is the 3O’s:  Organisers Organise Organisations – in other words, the focus of organisers is the creation of an authentic and organic people’s organisation. On the other hand, organisers are encouraged to avoid existing community organisations that will distract from, bias or seek to direct the organiser’s work. The current drive for ‘partnership working’ is explicitly rejected by community organisers as an imposition on the community of another agenda.

Robot Org-chart by MattHirstThe best of worlds, the worst of worlds

This dual nature to organisations is all around us. As employees and other participants in organisational life, we know that they give us access to resources and technical specialisms held only in such settings. We know they allow us to share knowledge over time and space and achieve the common task in effective ways. They can channel leadership to a complex goal and provide us with a routine and social support for the journey to completion. Organisations are immensely positive influences on our lives.

Organisations though also have a darker side. We have all been aware of organisations dominating the thinking of the individual through their culture, brand and ethos. They can unwittingly limit the options leading to ‘group think’, blocking out strong evidence because it does not fit the parameters of the group’s world view. On the receiving end of organisational culture, we can feel oppressed and our opinion ignored. We can recognise that the necessary bureaucracy of organisational life has become a cause in itself.

Nawal El Saadawi@OCCUPY LONDON 22 11 20 by wheelzwheelerOccupy – leaderless but not rudderless

It is the negative side of organisations that has led the Occupy movement across the world to remain leaderless. No one person or hierarchy of people can speak for the movement. Decisions are made in daily people’s assemblies. The culture and priorities are contested and emergent, the actions planned swiftly using secure online networks. Rather than leading to anarchy, such inclusive forms of democracy are paving the way for a different form of dispersed organisation that has only become possible with the evolution of mobile social networking.

The capacity of organisations of all sizes and types to create an acceptable ‘way of being’, of socialising us into their norms is undoubted. People will act in the strangest of ways when commanded to do so; they will also do the most heroic acts of bravery under direction. But this cultural formation has detrimental effects when it is imposed on others who do not have the power to resist. We have recently been reminded of the role that institutional racism played in the Stephen Lawrence investigation. Actions that are taken in good faith within the organisational culture can appear bizarre or cruel from outside.

Race California by toastforbrekkieStripping back the organisational clothing

This week I have been thinking about the way local authorities and other public bodies undertake community consultation. From my experience in Southwark, it appears to have strongly detrimental impacts, leaving the majority of the citizens feeling ignored. ‘They just don’t listen’ is a constant cry at doorstep after doorstep. Yet I have also every confidence that the members and officers of the Council are trying their hardest to listen to citizens’ concerns. The problem is their organisational clothing; they are unable to shed the council’s world view and approach their community members stripped of corporate assumptions.

The distance between the culture of corporate Britain and community life is explored in a telling discussion paper (see below) by Eileen Conn who is a Southwark resident and long-time community activist. She highlights the complete misunderstanding in most large (and small) organisations of the alternative style at the heart of community life. As a consequence, the attempts at dialogue between state agencies, business or the voluntary sector and the grassroots is doomed to failure. Her paper is a wake up call to a deeper and more transformative approach to relationship building at community level.

Close up Grass by Sam KimStreet level organising

As I said at the opening of this post, community organising is about creating an authentic people’s organisation from the grassroots. Organisers are not the leaders of this evolving organisation, community members are. Organisers do not set the agenda or chose the priorities, community members do that. By listening, heeding and reflecting, organisers enable and facilitate citizens to develop their own politics of the everyday, shaping their organisation to suit the task of holding power with the people. Staying alongside people from all parts of Southwark life, we are working to develop a responsive, reflective and radically distinctive network of groups and individuals ready to take action for the common good.

Resources

Eileen Conn (2011) Community Engagement and the Social Eco-System Dance Third Sector Research Centre

Richard C. Harwood and John C. Creighton (2009) The Organization-First Approach: How Programs Crowd out Community Kettering Foundation

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Power and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Living with organisations

  1. Eileen Conn says:

    well said Mark. We have to make a breakthrough in awareness of these dynamics if we are going to escape from the trenches of repetitive failure in trying to develop effective ways to engage us all in meeting the challenges of our neighbourhoods and more. I hope some of your readers will read my paper (link in your post) and give us their resposnes to it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s